Which experience comes first – emotional or bodily?

Psychology

Home » Psychology » Which experience comes first – emotional or bodily?

According to most psychologists, common sense suggests that because our emotions are involuntary, any action taken must come after the emotion. For example, if you’re afraid of bears, you’ll run away from them. But according to many psychologists, the order is reversed, so that your fear causes your body to react before your brain does. William James and Carl Langs proposed that the first response to stress is physical – increased heart rates and tremors. These are actually caused by our emotions and they actually affect how we feel. Other studies have shown physical changes can actually change emotions and the way we feel about things.

In spite of the wide acceptance of the James–Lange Theory, later psychologists such as Walter Cannon and Philip Bard argued that the physiological and emotional responses are simultaneous rather than sequential. They claimed that we assess the situation and then produce an emotion. Richard Lazarus argued that we make a cognitive judgment about a situation, triggering an emotional response. Recently, Robert Zajonc has argued that our thoughts and feelings are different processes, and that common sense may be correct in assuming that our initial reaction is emotional.

Connect

Latest posts:

Mind and brain

In many cultures around this world, there is the view that humans have a soul that exists independently of the physical body. For Greek philosophers, the soul was also viewed as the seat of our reasoning abilities - what we would call our minds today. While Aristotle...

Precursors of psychology

The natural sciences (physics, astronomy, chemistry, biology, and geology) developed out of philosophical speculations about the nature of reality. However, it wasn’t till the late nineteenth century that a systematic study of human thought emerged. One reason for...

Neuroscience

Around the middle of the nineteenth century, medical science turned its attention to disorders of the central nervous system. Early neuroscientists, including Jean-Martin Charcot, examined and documented conditions, such as multiple scleroses, prompting research into...

Medical conditions

Throughout history, mental health issues have been treated with suspicion, sometimes leading to fear. Some conditions, including depression and schizophrenia, have been blamed on supernatural forces; others, such as anxiety, have been associated with certain bodily...

Hypnosis

In the late eighteenth century, Austrian doctor Franz Anton Mesmer developed an approach to treating illness based on the idea that disease could be caused by a disturbance in the body's natural energy flow and cured by restoring the correct flow. He believed he could...



Free Semiology Course


Check it out!

Free Course in Semiology

 

A completely and truly free course on Semiology (Semiotics). Learn about the meaning of signs, how and why did the field emerged. What is the relationship between the street signs and the signs that we use every day - words.

 

Learn Semiology